Connecting Regions of Asia.

The Heroic Indian Soldier, Bulwark Against Chinese Designs


On May 9, as Indian and Chinese troops clashed at Naku La (Sikkim) following on a similar clash at Pangong Tso on May 5,  the Dragon Warriors got a taste of the assertive Indian soldier who was not afraid to take them on.
As one Chinese Major moved menacingly towards an Indian captain of the Assam regiment, young wiry lieutenant Birol Das flew into him to land a powerful punch. The Chinese hit the ground, bleeding . The young Birol then fought back other Chinese . But when he returned to his camp, he was pulled up for being too aggressive with questions of “whether you want to start another Doklam”. Later he was pulled back to a rear camp .When I wrote the story for the Quint, the management was asked by the army to take his name off. ” Or else it would be difficult to save him,” said some officers. The Chinese were upset because a ‘small lieutenant’ meaning junior) had punched a ‘Big’ (senior) Chinese officer. 

Lt. Birol Das and Chinese Major

The story garnered 323K hits , was tweeted by many bigwigs but Birol remained depressed, fearing the disclosure would ruin his career. Though he had not spoken to me and his father stonewalled all queries (because he had been told by the army to avoid media) , some other officers came out with the story because the saga of Birol had spread in the rank and file.But an ultra-defensive army leadership, keener to prevent a possible escalation than facing down the Chinese intruders, and backed by a panicky, chicken-hearted political leadership which had provoked a confrontation by threatening to recapture Aksai Chin but then seemed desperate to avoid taking on the Chinese, passed fatwas that soldiers and their families should not talk to media. 
Ashis Das, whom I have known since childhood , stopped talking my calls , imagining that his son’s career has been ruined by my reporting which was aimed at boosting the Indian army morale and reporting an actual incident on ground , garnered from multiple sources.  I requested some army friends to ensure no harm came to Birol because my reporting was not based on his account or his father.  The boy who deserved a Chief’s Commendation at least, got pushed around for something he had not done — disclosure.

Birol Das with his family

Also, a military school product, I failed to understand why the Indian army was not interested in building up its heroes gallery against China , since the border face-offs seemed long haul. 
My father and Ashis’ had served in the IAF , we have been to a primary school at Kanpur for a while and then briefly caught up in army parties and in programmes of a military think-tank CENERS-K.
But despite the treatment Birol got — and I hope the top brass sets the record straight and rewards rather than punish the teenage officer — the saga of the assertive Indian soldier, the only real card India has against the marauding Chinese , had began to unfold in this conflict season of 2020. 
This is a saga of bravery that the Chinese had only experienced at the peak of their revolutionary fervour during the Long March in the battles of An Jen Chang and Tatu Ho — but that has eluded the Chinese since the thrashing they got in Vietnam 1979, when they lost 33,000 soldiers in 9 days.
From Major Shaitan Singh of Rezang La in 1962 to Major Vikram Batra in Kargil 1999 , thousands of junior commanders and johnnies (soldiers) had upheld the glorious Indian army tradition of the super-soldier by fighting against insurmountable odds in war after war .
Remember the 6th Rajputs who lost 582 of the 613 men, including their CO, in the first Chinese blitz at Thagla Ridge on 20 oct, 1962. Nobody ran away , they fought , as Dalvi recounts, before they were killed or captured with severe injuries.
The grand Kshatriya tradition, reinforced by much martial traditions of India’s fighting races from  the Sikhs to the Gorkhas to the Nagas , has no parallel in China and only a parallel in Japan’s Samurui tradition which has been discontinued after the Second World War.
The summer of 2020 would be no different. Despite the government’s gag on detailed news about exploits of the likes of Birol and Gurtej , the stories have filtered out.  Unlike the ‘sanitized coverage’ from defence beat reporters in Delhi singing the 3D tune — Defuse, De-escalate, Disengage– , it has been Easternlink’s pleasure to be at the forefront of reporting the unparalleled bravery of the Indian soldier in one battle theatre after another. 
The most poignant was that of 3rd Punjab ‘Ghatak’ battalion Sepoy Gurtej Singh who killed 12 Chinese on the that fateful 15 June clash before he fell dead.

Gurtej Singh  
Easternlink is happy to learn that the Punjab government will name the school in Gurtej’s native village after him and will possibly bestow a huge cash and kind reward for his family .

Due to the gag on the Army , the heroic stories of 15th June are slowly filtering.
Another Sikh gunner Surinder Singh , an Amritdhari , is reported to have killed 8 to 10 Chinese alone — slashing with kirpan , snatching a Chinese sword and then swinging to devastating effect.
Lt Col Maninder Nagpal (2i/C) , Capt Arjun Deshpande and Captain Manangma , all of 16th Bihar, also stood their ground like men possessed and fought much larger Chinese numbers with unusual bravery . 
Army Chief Gen M M Naravane has honoured 5 soldiers but it was not clear who were they and which unit they belonged. I have not seen any media report on these awards.
The Indian army should take a leaf out of the Soviet playbook of how they turned sniper Vasilly Zaitsev of Stalingrad fame into a hero whose story struck terror in Nazi heart.
It never serves an army right if it gagged the exploits of its braveheart and failed to honor their supreme sacrifice — it impacts on morale and much else.The 3Ds– defuse, de-escalate, disengage — better be left to politicians and diplomats and the field commanders, who have always every face-off from Chumar to Depsang to Doklam India’s way and forced the Chinese to blink, be allowed to take firm local initiative, like Gen Sundarji allowed Lt Gen J M Singh during Ops Chequerboard and Falcon in 1986 ( which I covered from the spot unlike the head-quarter reporters)  .  I recall doing a Reuters story ” Sino-Indian loudspeaker war on the Himalayas” which swept the western media and which was much appreciated by none other than Sundarji.

This time, my experience has been different. Kill this story, avoid reference to names, reveal the source — such requests have flown from the top. 
But I am proud to say that my stories on first Birol, then Gurtej has rekindled the public desire to know about the bravehearts who stopped the Chinamen , often with bare hands , in the high Himalayas in May-June  .
 Birol is a technical graduate from Calcutta, but one who chose his father’s Assam regimen as sister Ashima joined the Army’s Legal Cell. For three generations, the Das family has been in the service of the nation.  Gurtej is a typical Sikh boy from rural Punjab. By the way,  these two provinces, which suffered most in Partition,  provided 80 percent of the inmates to Andaman Cellular Jail during India’s freedom struggle. 

Gurtej Singh

As India gags the public gaze on its heroes amid PM Modi’s desperate de-escalation effort (his “no Chinese intrusion” speech provoked a furious reaction from hundred of veterans) , the Chinese netizens are in angry mode, many asking why Xi’s government is suppressing casualties . 
List of dead soldiers soldiers are circulating in the Chinese social media, picked up by some alert Indian netizens with military background . The Chinese are saying they have not suffered more than 40 casualties India media has reported — but they are taking a high moral ground that lack of disclosure is aimed at de-escalation. In reality, the Chinese have taken much casualties than what was reported in the ‘sanitized’ Indian media — 20 odd in the brawls, 29 in the revenge bayonet charges , 25 in the landslide which India blames on operation of Chinese bulldozers but which Chinese blame on an Indian hilltop blast with explosives meant for road building. 

Much credit must also go to 14th Corps Commander Lt Gen Harinder Singh whose brilliant tactical moves and spirited ripostes has the Chinese in confusion. Chinese netizens, who were celebrating Indian media reports of his possible removal to prevent escalation, are now dismayed at his continuation of command. Veterans say he is clearly a “Chief Material” , his only weakness is he lacks the political skill of ‘butter-and-oil’ to make it to the very top.

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

  1. Arnab Sinha says

    Dear Mr. Bhaumik,
    Many thanks for your coverage of the recent happenings in Ladakh. Commoners like me wouldn’t have known the real facts otherwise. Please do keep up this great work.
    Best regards,
    Arnab Sinha

    1. amrik says

      The story has many holes. Has the reporter talked to the prisoners released. First of all it was said that the soldiers were not armed from both sides. Secondaly no one has reported any eye witness.

  2. gui says

    Ha, ha, ha, smile dead brother, Indian soldiers flee for life, like a rabbit left 17 comrades, so that they were to freeze to death, and then choose a live in rabbit as a hero to brag about.

    If this rabbit is so powerful, why not save a few comrades back?

    1. Kumar says

      Hey stinky filth. All big empires fell when they grow in their f’ing ego. You chinky rat eating bastards have too much ego. Just wait you all will laying railway lines in the west. You sh*t eating stinky yellow m’fkers.

  3. Abdullah says

    A boastful and bragging article. Let me call it pack of lies. Reportedly total chinese casualties were Four only with less than 10 injured against 38 indians dead and 76 under treatment in indian hospitals….

    1. amrik says

      You might be right. What is the source. India saying 20 killed 20 captured.

  4. gui says

    I saw your sister get on the bus alone!

  5. Surinder Singh says

    A few comments.
    A very good article by Subeer da.
    They say it’s not the gun but the man behind the gun which matters.
    Now going back in history this same China’s Emperor’s beard was pulled and was thrown down from his throne by a Mongol nomad chief resulting in construction of the Great wall to keep these invaders at bay.
    Coming to present conflict with China arguements are given their GDP is 5x of ours, their war machine is much advanced,bigger than ours etc etc.
    To hell with all that.
    We can akso grow gradually if we maintain discipline. But the political class and these so called religious Babas have looted the country most.
    Now whatever 70 sq. km area China has occupied we have to take back come whatsoever hell or high water.
    Also a long term proactive policy against China has to be in place which should be closely monitored, reviewed, amended as needed because we have a very cunning, deceitful neighborhood.
    What is most appalling is the veterans on TV channels often suggest a political solution to the problem where there is none.
    Also the govt has stooge in all key posns like chief election commission,army generals etc. The man calling the shots is the NSA.
    This is the time of a war cry.We have to stand up, take the challenge and beat the hell out of the Chinese and put them on their knees.
    We are ready to fight alongside our army, ancestors have a long fighting history even before the 1st world war.
    Now about out country from pre indedepence era there has been injustice by the system Great Leaders like Subash Chandra Bose have been side lined.
    The jokers ruling the country
    reminds me of Churchill’s words these men of straw can’t rule.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More